Creators: earn 10% per sale. Join the affiliate program
top of page
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
Search

Water Purification Tablets vs Water Filter: Which to Keep?

Nov 3
9 min read

Updated: 2 days ago

Tablets and filters both promise "safe water," but they do very different jobs. A filter strains things out of water. A tablet or powder kills germs with chemicals. Neither one does everything, which is why the best answer for most kits is not "which one" but "which one first." This guide explains what each method does and doesn't do, based on CDC and EPA guidance, when to keep each one, and how to use them together.

Quick answer

Keep both if you can. Filter first, then disinfect. That's the order the CDC recommends when you can't boil: "The next best option is to filter water and then disinfect the filtered water" (CDC).

  • If you can only keep one for a go-bag or car, keep water purification tablets. They're tiny, light and, per the CDC, chemical disinfectants kill viruses and bacteria, which most portable filters don't remove (CDC). Check the label, though: some tablets, like Potable Aqua iodine tablets, are labeled for bacteria and Giardia only.

  • If you'll be treating a lot of water at home, a filter is the workhorse, but follow it with a disinfectant, because the CDC says portable filters will not remove viruses (CDC).

  • If you can boil, boil. The CDC calls boiling "the best way to kill germs in water" (CDC).

And one limit applies to all of them: you can't make water with fuel, toxic chemicals or radioactive material safe by boiling or disinfecting it (CDC).

What water purification tablets do (and don't do)

Water purification tablets and powders are chemical disinfectants. Common types are iodine, chlorine and chlorine dioxide tablets, plus unscented household bleach.

What they do

  • Kill bacteria and, for many products, viruses. The CDC says "chemical disinfectants kill viruses and bacteria" (CDC). Check each product's label for what it's registered to kill.

  • Pack small. A bottle of tablets fits in a pocket of almost any bag, which is why they show up in so many go-bags and car kits.

  • Treat a set amount of water. The CDC notes that chemical disinfectants are made to disinfect specific amounts of water, so the label tells you how many tablets per quart or liter (CDC).

What they don't do

  • They may not kill parasites. The CDC says disinfectants "do not work as well as boiling" against the parasites Cryptosporidium and Giardia. Iodine and chlorine tablets "will not kill Cryptosporidium germs." Chlorine dioxide tablets will, if you follow the instructions correctly (CDC).

  • They don't clear dirty water. The EPA says disinfection "does not work as well when water is cloudy or colored," so settle and strain murky water first (EPA).

  • They don't remove chemicals. The EPA says boiling or disinfection will not destroy heavy metals, salts and most other chemicals (EPA).

  • They aren't instant. Every product has a wait (contact) time on the label. The CDC's advice is simply to follow the label of the product you use (CDC).

Who should avoid iodine

The CDC says that if you are pregnant, have thyroid problems or have a hypersensitivity to iodine, you should avoid drinking water disinfected with iodine, and no one should drink iodine-treated water for more than a few weeks at a time (CDC). That makes iodine tablets a short-term emergency tool, not a long-term water plan.

What a portable water filter does (and doesn't do)

A filter pushes water through a material with tiny holes. What it removes depends on the size of those holes, so the specs on the box matter more than the brand.

What filters do

  • Remove parasites if the filter has an absolute pore size of 1 micron or smaller, or is certified to NSF Standard 53 or 58 for cyst reduction or removal (CDC).

  • Remove bacteria if the absolute pore size is 0.3 micron or smaller (CDC).

  • Handle volume. You can keep filtering as long as the filter keeps working, with no tablets to run out of.

What filters don't do

  • Most don't remove viruses. The CDC is blunt: portable filters "will not remove viruses." The exception it lists is reverse osmosis, which removes parasites, bacteria and viruses (CDC).

  • Many don't remove bacteria. The CDC says most portable filters "will remove parasites, but not viruses or bacteria" (CDC). Check for that 0.3 micron rating.

  • They don't make chemically contaminated water safe. Same rule as tablets: if the water may have fuel or toxic chemicals in it, use another source and contact your health department (CDC).

Want help picking a filter? Our guide on how to find the best water filter for emergencies covers gravity, squeeze, pump and straw filters. This post is about how tablets fit around whatever filter you choose.

Tablets vs filter: side-by-side comparison

What you care about

Tablets or powder

Portable filter

Filter, then tablets

Bacteria

Kills them (CDC)

Only if 0.3 micron or smaller

Covered

Viruses

Kills them, per the CDC (check the label)

Not removed (except reverse osmosis)

Covered

Giardia and Cryptosporidium

May not kill; iodine and chlorine won't kill Crypto

Removed if 1 micron or smaller, or NSF 53/58 cyst

Covered by the filter

Cloudy or muddy water

Works less well; settle and strain first

Can clog; settle first

Settle, filter, then treat

Fuel or toxic chemicals

Not made safe

Not made safe

Not made safe; find another source

Wait before drinking

Label contact time

Drink once filtered

Label contact time

Size in a kit

Very small

Larger

Both

The water treatment we sell, and what each is for

We carry three chemical treatment options. None of them replaces a filter's job of removing parasites, and a filter doesn't replace their job of killing viruses, so think of them as partners.

Potable Aqua Water Purification Tablets

Potable Aqua Water Purification Tablets are iodine tablets made for treating water you already have. Tablets treat water; they don't store it, so they go with stored water and a container, not instead of them. Use the dose and wait time printed on the package, and remember the CDC's iodine cautions above. Its EPA-registered label says it's effective against Giardia and bacteria when used as directed, for short-term emergency use. The label doesn't claim it kills viruses, and it hasn't been shown to inactivate Cryptosporidium.

Best for: go-bags, car kits and get-home bags where space is tight.

Potable Aqua P.A. Plus 2 Step Water Treatment

Potable Aqua P.A. Plus 2 Step Water Treatment pairs the treatment tablets with a second P.A. Plus tablet that neutralizes the aftertaste and improves flavor. If the iodine taste would stop you from drinking enough water, this is the version to keep. Not for anyone pregnant, with thyroid problems, or sensitive to iodine (CDC). Follow the package for dosing, wait times and when to add the second step. Wait at least 30 minutes after the first step before adding P.A. Plus, as the label directs.

Best for: adults who'd otherwise skip drinking enough because of the iodine taste.

Chlor Floc Military Water Purification Powder

Chlor Floc Military Water Purification Powder comes in powder packets for emergency treatment of polluted or suspect water. Used exactly as the label directs, it clarifies (settles out sediment) and disinfects the water. Each packet treats 1 liter. The label calls for 1 packet per liter at about 77°F and 2 packets per liter in cold water (about 41°F).

Best for: murky water, since it's made to settle out sediment as well as disinfect.

When to keep tablets, a filter, or both

Shelter-in-place at home

Start with stored water. Use our emergency water calculator and storage checklist to figure out how much your household needs. Then keep a household-size filter for refills plus tablets or Chlor Floc to disinfect after filtering. If you still have a working stove, boiling is the CDC's top choice.

Under a boil water advisory, follow your water utility's instructions. Our boil water advisory guide explains how it differs from a do-not-drink notice and what to do. Keep treated water covered in a clean container with a tight cap (CDC), such as an empty 5-gallon water jug.

Go-bag, car kit or get-home bag

Weight and space win here. Keep a small filter plus a bottle of tablets. If you truly have room for only one, tablets labeled for viruses cover bacteria and viruses in very little space, but know their parasite limits.

Cloudy, muddy or flood-area water

Look for a better source first. The EPA says flowing water is generally better than still, stagnant water, and to avoid water with floating material, a dark color or a questionable odor (EPA). If the water may contain fuel or chemicals, don't drink it at all. For cloudy water you have to use, settle it, strain it, then filter and treat.

Long emergencies

Iodine is not for more than a few weeks per the CDC, so a long event needs a filter plus a non-iodine disinfectant (or boiling) as your main plan.

Step by step: how to filter and disinfect water together

  1. Pick the best source you can. Flowing beats stagnant. Skip water with floating material, dark color, an odd smell, or any chance of fuel or chemicals (EPA).

  2. Let cloudy water settle. Then pour off the clearer water, or strain it through a clean cloth, paper towel or coffee filter (CDC).

  3. Run it through your filter. Follow the filter maker's instructions (CDC).

  4. Add your disinfectant to the filtered water. The CDC recommends adding a chemical disinfectant after filtering to kill viruses and bacteria (CDC). Use a product labeled for what you need it to kill, and use the dose on the label for the amount of water you have.

  5. Wait the full time on the label. Don't drink early.

  6. Store it covered. Keep treated water in clean, sanitized containers with tight covers (CDC).

Backup: plain bleach

No tablets left? The EPA says to use regular, unscented chlorine bleach (not scented, color-safe or with added cleaners). For clear water, add 8 drops of 6% bleach or 6 drops of 8.25% bleach per gallon, double it if the water is cloudy, colored or very cold, stir, and let it stand 30 minutes. The water should have a slight chlorine smell. If it doesn't, repeat the dose and wait another 15 minutes (EPA). Always check your bottle's label for its concentration and any drinking-water directions first (CDC).

Printable water treatment checklist

Print this and keep it with your water supplies.

  • Stored drinking water for every person and pet (see the water calculator)

  • Portable filter rated 0.3 micron or smaller, or NSF 53/58 for cysts (check the box)

  • Spare filter cartridge or cleaning parts for your filter

  • Water purification tablets or powder, with the package directions kept with them

  • Taste neutralizer (like P.A. Plus) if the iodine taste would stop you from drinking enough water

  • A non-iodine backup for long events or anyone pregnant or with thyroid issues

  • Unscented household bleach (6% or 8.25%) and a clean dropper

  • Clean cloth, paper towels or coffee filters for pre-straining

  • Two marked containers: one "dirty," one "treated"

  • A clean container with a tight lid for treated water

  • A pot and a way to boil water, if you have one

  • Check expiration dates on tablets and bleach every time you change your clocks

FAQ

Are water purification tablets better than a filter?

Neither is better at everything. Per the CDC, chemical disinfectants kill bacteria and viruses but may not kill parasites, while most portable filters remove parasites but not viruses. Using a filter and then a disinfectant covers both (CDC). Check each tablet's label for what it covers.

Can I drink stream water with just a filter?

The CDC says clear water can still be unsafe and that "drinking water straight from a clear mountain stream is generally not safe" (CDC). Since most portable filters don't remove viruses, follow filtering with a disinfectant, or boil.

Do tablets make floodwater safe?

Not if it may contain fuel or toxic chemicals. The CDC says boiling or disinfecting can't make that water safe (CDC). Use stored water or another source, and contact your health department.

How long can I use iodine tablets?

The CDC says no one should drink iodine-disinfected water for more than a few weeks at a time, and people who are pregnant, have thyroid problems or are iodine-sensitive should avoid it (CDC).

Can water purification tablets replace a filter?

Not completely. Tablets kill bacteria and, for many products, viruses, but iodine and chlorine tablets won't kill Cryptosporidium, which a filter with a pore size of 1 micron or smaller removes (CDC). For a go-bag, tablets alone are the light choice. At home or in a long emergency, keep a filter too and disinfect after filtering.

Is boiling better than both?

The CDC calls boiling the best way to kill germs. Bring clear water to a rolling boil for 1 minute. Above 5,000 feet, boil for 3 minutes (EPA; the CDC's cutoff is 6,500 feet, so 5,000 covers both). Tablets and filters matter when you can't boil, or when you need water on the move.

Related guides

Sources

Get Ready Now: Shop Emergency Disaster Products

Stock up on essential emergency supplies today — food, water, shelter, and more. Be ready for anything.



 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page